Good afternoon, I am Gail Lynch-Bailey, President of the Middle Island Civic Association
Thanks for this opportunity to speak about The Meadows at Artist Lake. The MI Civic Association has been meeting with the developer’s reps, and the TOB as well as those from our essential community partners, the Longwood Central School District and MI Fire Dept, since April 2024 to learn about, comment on and shape this project which is very much indeed a Development of Regional Significance.
The civic has not yet taken a position on this proposal. That’s because the one meeting we have yet to participate in is an open community meeting, wherein the developer presents the plan to the public, answers questions and gathers feedback. This will finally happen on Thursday, December 10, 2026 at 7pm at Longwood Public Library. Town Councilman Mike Loguercio will co-host this session with us. Here is the flyer for this meeting. The opportunity for the public to make in-person comments is important.
This is not to say that the public isn’t aware of the plan and its evolution. We have been reporting on negotiations at our monthly civic meetings, on social media and our website. The original Meadows plan called for 430 rental units across nine four-story buildings. We don’t even have a three story building in MI – and the MIFD doesn’t have equipment for four stories. The submitted plan now contains 295 units, half of which will be age-restricted , a good concession to the school district’s concerns. And it does not contain the huge fuel station that was part of the plan detailed on your March 18 agenda earlier this year. I wrote to you about this in April, citing economic and environmental concerns. We are greatly relieved at its elimination.
Another item on that March 18 agenda that is missing from today’s is the term “community park.” I note staff’s request for more information and figures about this. What I want to make sure you understand is how this compares with the plan approved in July 2011 as a DRS. That plan, which contained no housing, called for not one but TWO baseball fields AND a third multi-purpose field, all on property owned by Mr. Breslin and Mr. Colin. It left the dog park intact on town property and depicted a stunning floating crescent-shaped dock at Artist Lake – a noted scenic resource.
Under the current plan, Artist Lake is ignored, the community park is relegated to town property, and the dog park faces restricted access, relocation or elimination. There are a few small public walking paths around what are recharge areas near the apartments. This pales in comparison to the 2011 plan, which again contained no housing. In addition to the traffic it will generate — and thank you for an honest traffic study that admits there WILL be more traffic– that housing will create the most troubling impact of all: an estimated sanitary wastewater flow rate of 60,645 gallons per day. This is nearly TRIPLE the ‘As Of Right’ flow of 22,272 gallons per day for the site. That’s an excess of 38, 373 gallons per day –across the street from Artist Lake, which is already surrounded by nearly a dozen high density housing complexes.
The protections created under the Pine Barrens Act are well known and respected by almost everyone in Suffolk County. The same cannot be said for the purchase of Pine Barrens Credits, which is being suggested as a solution to the Meadows developer. Forking over a bunch of cash does nothing to eliminate on-site adverse environmental impacts . Nor does it help the local communities that will be most affected and possibly placed at risk. Yes, the Open Space being preserved is a beautiful thing, although I was surprised to learn that it will remain in private hands under a conservation easement and not go to the TOB — I laways learn new things at PBC Hearings! But this Open Space is slightly less than that of the DRS approved in 2011, which offered far greater public amenities. More intensive use, fewer public benefits. That’s simple math.
Thank you. Happy Thanksgiving.
